Game Awards Best Independent Game prediction: Big Walk costs too much

Big Walk is the favorite with a very awkward footnote.

FADE Big Walk beside Game of the Year awards stage
(Image via Spilled)
Our Call

Fade Big Walk

low confidence

Big Walk sits at 51% on Polymarket, yet Dexerto reports some judges said they wouldn't vote for games that used generative tools.
We think this is less likely than its price says, so buy No.

Buy no at

No on Big Walk at 51¢ on Polymarket

Our chance for No

55%

Call date

Nov 21, 2026

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 won Best Independent Game last year, then took Game of the Year too, and plenty of people said it didn’t belong in the category. This year no indie game is up for Game of the Year, so this trophy is the biggest indie moment of the night. Five games want it, from the Untitled Goose Game team’s new walker to a gothic Zelda-like from the Shovel Knight studio.

Our call is a Fade on Big Walk, with low confidence. Polymarket has it at 51% and Kalshi at 54%, and both venues have it as the favorite. We put it at 45%, so No on Polymarket at 51¢ is the side we like.

The case for Big Walk is real. It has four nominations in total and is the only Best Independent Game nominee also up for Best Multiplayer, which points to broad jury support. GameSpot also lists it with Mina the Hollower among the highest-rated games of 2026 on Metacritic. But the jury holds most of the vote, and House House’s disclosure that chatbot output touched a small part of its code hurt it with some judges. Dexerto reports that some said they wouldn’t vote for games that used generative tools. Mina the Hollower had a perfect score from IGN before launch, and Mewgenics sold a million copies in a week, so the field isn’t weak.

Game Awards Best Independent Game odds on Polymarket and Kalshi

Ties are the key difference. Polymarket gives a tie to the nominee whose title comes first alphabetically, while Kalshi has a separate Tie outcome, so the same result can pay differently depending on where you trade. Big Walk is cheaper on Polymarket, at 51¢ against 54¢ on Kalshi. Mina the Hollower costs 35¢ on both, and Mewgenics is cheaper on Kalshi (14¢ against 15¢).

OutcomePolymarket7-day move
Big Walk51¢up 9 pts
Mina the Hollower35¢up 2 pts
Mewgenics15¢up 5 pts
Cairn6¢up 2 pts
Denshattack3¢—
Polymarket odds as of November 21, 16:31 UTC. A share pays $1 if it happens, so 73¢ means a 73% chance. A dash in the move column means the market is less than a week old, so it has no 7-day move. $90,000 traded on Polymarket.
OutcomeKalshi7-day move
Big Walk54¢up 12 pts
Mina the Hollower35¢up 2 pts
Mewgenics14¢up 7 pts
Cairn3¢up 1 pt
Denshattack2¢—
Kalshi odds as of November 21, 16:31 UTC. A dash in the move column means the market is less than a week old, so it has no 7-day move. $34,000 traded on Kalshi. One more outcome isn’t shown.

Big Walk keeps climbing anyway

Big Walk is up 12 points on Kalshi and up 9 points on Polymarket over the week. The timing fits the nominations: It kept both of them after the disclosure, and its Steam reviews have since recovered to Very Positive. Mina the Hollower is up 2 points on Kalshi and Mewgenics is up 7 points. Mewgenics is down 3 points over the last day, while Cairn is flat.

Big Walk price on Polymarket and KalshiThe daily midpoint for Big Walk on Polymarket went from 47¢ on October 25 to 50¢ on November 21. The daily midpoint for Big Walk on Kalshi went from 47¢ on October 23 to 54¢ on November 21.PolymarketKalshi0¢50¢100¢Oct 23Nov 21Our call47¢47¢54¢50¢Big Walk price on Polymarket and KalshiThe daily midpoint for Big Walk on Polymarket went from 47¢ on October 25 to 50¢ on November 21. The daily midpoint for Big Walk on Kalshi went from 47¢ on October 23 to 54¢ on November 21.PolymarketKalshi0¢50¢100¢Oct 23Nov 21Our call47¢47¢54¢50¢
Big Walk on Polymarket and Kalshi, October 23 to November 21: the daily midpoint between the best bid and ask. The board above shows the price to buy.

How it resolves

Polymarket: The market resolves to the listed game that wins the 2026 Game Award for Best Independent Game. A game that isn’t officially nominated resolves to “No” as soon as the nominees are announced. A tie goes to the nominated game whose title comes first alphabetically. If no winner is declared by the rules’ year-end deadline in 2026, it resolves to “Other”. The sources are official Game Awards information, meaning the website and live broadcast, and credible reporting may also be used.

Kalshi: Unlike Polymarket, Kalshi runs one market per outcome, and each resolves Yes if that game wins Best Independent Game at the 2026 Game Awards. It has a separate “Tie” outcome instead of an alphabetical tiebreak. Its rules name no resolution source. Kalshi expects to settle it by December 31.

Explore More
Meet the Editor
mm
Editor-in-Chief